While much is written about HRP in theory, evidence about its application in practice is harder to obtain. The Workplace Employee Relations Survey (Cully et al., 1999) reports that 91 per cent of managers with senior responsibility for employment relations include ‘staffing or manpower planning’ in their list of tasks.
Analysis of data from the three most recent workplace surveys (Millward et al., 2000) shows a shift in responsibility for HRP. The proportion of HR specialists with responsibility for HRP declined from 87 per cent in 1984 to 80 per cent in 1990 and remained stable at 80 per cent in 1998, while the proportion of non-specialists with responsibility for HRP has increased from 85 per cent in 1984 to 90 per cent in 1998. This could be seen as indicative of a general trend · Human resource planning
The ability to forecast accurately is central to effective planning strategies. If the forecasts turn out to be wrong, the real costs and opportunity costs … can be considerable. On the other hand, if they are correct they can provide a great deal of benefit – if the competitors have not followed similar planning strategies.
(Makridakis, 1990 cited in Mintzberg, 1994: 229) in the devolution of people management matters to line and general managers. However, HRP seems to be a unique case as, of the six HR functions covered in the surveys, reduced responsibility for HRP is ‘the only enduring change’ (Millward et al., 2000: 62). There are significant sectoral variations in this shift: the proportion of HR specialists with responsibility for ‘staffing or manpower planning’ declined in the private sector but increased substantially in the public sector.
However, the scope for different interpretations inherent in the term ‘staffing or manpower planning’ means that we know little about the type of HRP activity actually carried out and so are unable to draw firm conclusions about the reasons for shifts in responsibility. There is also the potential danger that the high proportion of respondents reporting HRP activity could be indicative of intent rather than actual practice. A number of authors (see, for example, Liff, 2000; Rothwell, 1995) have noted the gap between widespread claims and relatively limited activity.
Storey (1992) observed that the majority of companies in his sample would have ‘ticked’ survey questions about HRP, but a substantial number were not doing it. In the past, studies investigating HRP in practice (e.g. Mackay and Torrington, 1986; Cowling and Walters, 1990) have tended to find evidence of only partial activity and limited implementation of any plans. Rothwell (1995: 178–179) suggests four principal reasons for the lack of empirical proof of HRP activity:
This last reason could help to account for the potential discrepancy between the proportion of managers reporting involvement in ‘staffing or manpower planning’ in WERS and the limited evidence of systematic planning activity in more detailed studies. In his study into people management practices in SMEs, Hendry (1995) found some evidence of HRP-related activities (e.g. managers considered recruitment and selection, training and pay in relation to issues identified in labour and product markets) but approaches tended to be tentative and incremental rather than classical and rational.
HR Management Related Tutorials
|SAP HR Tutorial|
Hr Management Tutorial
An Introduction To Human Resource Management: Strategy, Style Or Outcome
Strategic Human Resource Management
Human Resource Management In Context
Human Resource Management And The Labour Market
Human Resource Planning
Recruitment And Selection
Managing Equality And Diversity
Learning And Development
Human Resource Development: The Organisation And The National Framework
The Employment Relationship And Employee Rights At Work
Establishing The Terms And Conditions Of Employment
Reward And Performance Management
Employee Involvement And Empowerment
Hrm In Multinationals: A Comparative International Perspective
Human Resource Management And Europe
Human Resource Management In Asia
All rights reserved © 2018 Wisdom IT Services India Pvt. Ltd
Wisdomjobs.com is one of the best job search sites in India.